Skip to content

AH-NFM-ACT-02 · Action

Commission Advice

Commission the question before the treatment.

Under technical reviewAH-NFM-ACT-02v1.0Registry revision: May 2026 · review not verified

Independent technical review is pending. Publication does not establish scientific approval.

Under editorial review — PDF not available for public download.

When to seek specialist advice

Seek experienced specialist advice where significance is high, identification is uncertain, deterioration appears active, structure or fixings may be failing, appearance-changing work is proposed, or designation may require consent.

Minimum contents of a specialist consultation brief

  • Asset identity and context — location, type, ownership, setting, designation, access.
  • Known significance — artist, maker, date, historic role, intended surface where known, evidential value.
  • Existing evidence — condition observations, photographs, reports, maintenance and intervention history.
  • Commission question — what the specialist is being asked to establish and advise on.
  • Requested scope — inspection, material and surface assessment, risk prioritisation, options, brief or specification, maintenance advice.
  • Permissions and project context — consent stage, owner approvals, programme, constraints.
  • Deliverables — illustrated report, drawings, trials and samples advice, record package, meeting or presentation.
  • Competence requirement — experience appropriate to material, asset, significance and intervention proposed.

Selecting competent specialists

  • Experience with the relevant material and type of heritage asset.
  • Relevant conservation accreditation or comparable demonstrable competence.
  • Examples of comparable assessment or treatment work.
  • Understanding of historic surfaces, documentation and maintenance.
  • Suitable professional indemnity, insurance and health-and-safety systems.
  • Clarity about subcontractors — access specialists, structural engineers, analysts, foundries.
  • Ability to provide robust records and communicate with the wider professional team.

Reviewing a proposed intervention — four gates

The four gates provide a consistent structure for reviewing any conservation proposal before approval.

Gate 1 · Significance and existing evidence

Has the proposal demonstrated understanding of the asset's significance, evidence for material identification (and any uncertainty), surface significance, dated condition evidence, and the whole assembly (fixings, armatures, joins, interfaces, water paths)?

Gate 2 · Purpose and proportionality

Is there a stated conservation objective rather than a general desire for improved appearance? Has minimum necessary intervention been considered? Has monitoring or no intervention been evaluated where reasonable? Are repair, restoration, replacement and replication clearly distinguished? Are uncertain findings treated honestly?

Gate 3 · Control of appearance-changing work

Cleaning, polishing, coating, repatination, repainting, regilding and visible replacement require evidence of intended or significant appearance; trial areas or samples; named approval points; method and material recording; protection of adjacent materials; and future maintenance commitments.

Gate 4 · Project completion and care

A proposal is incomplete without final photographic and written records; handover of material and treatment information; an inspection and maintenance schedule; triggers for reassessment; and confirmation of any permissions and approval compliance.

Tender and contract review checklist

  • Separate price for assessment / trials and approved works.
  • Method statements tied to approved objectives.
  • Sample or trial acceptance process.
  • Named practitioners and responsibilities.
  • Access, safety and environmental controls.
  • Records and handover requirements.
  • Defects, aftercare and inspection arrangements.

Need project-specific advice?

Arts Heritage is a conservation practice. For advice on a particular asset or proposal, contact Arts Heritage ↗.